Why False DV Charges Are So Common

Why these offenses are so common
While positive domestic violence awareness spreads, a new DV-related issue has begun to arise. People across the country are falsely claiming that their spouse or significant other has tried to attack them.

Why are false domestic violence charges so common? Laws have been put into place to help ensure victims and their children are protected. These laws are now being taken advantage of by people who are trying to exact revenge or gain an upper hand in divorce proceedings.

The Penalties Are Very Serious

When a person falsely accuses another of a crime, that person usually wants to exact revenge, obtain custody, or profit in one way or another. Not all crimes result in serious penalties, but a domestic violence conviction is considered a serious violent offense, and the laws reflect that.

Domestic violence is defined under California Penal Code Section 243(e)(1) as battery committed against:

  • A spouse or former spouse
  • A person with whom the defendant is cohabiting
  • The parent of the defendant’s child
  • A fiancé or fiancée
  • Someone with whom the defendant is dating or is engaged, or someone with whom they have previously been dating or engaged.

Section 273.5 further addresses domestic violence as any willful conduct that leads to “corporal injury that results in a traumatic condition” upon:

  • A spouse or former spouse
  • A cohabitant or former cohabitant
  • A fiancé or fiancée
  • Someone with whom the defendant is dating or is engaged, or someone with whom they have previously been dating or engaged
  • The mother or father of that defendant’s child

If charged under Penal Section 243(e)(1) a domestic violence is punishable by up to a year in jail and a fine of up to $2000, or both. And When charged under Section 273.5, it is a felony, punishable by up to 4 years in state prison and a fine of up to $6000, or both.

As you can see, any allegation of domestic violence is a serious matter that neither the accused nor the accuser can take lightly after the process has been set into motion.

It Gives The Accuser The Upper Hand

Domestic violence is one of those crimes where a lot of false accusations are made and a lot of innocent people get wrongly charged and sometimes wrongly convicted. False charges usually occur when the couple is:

  1. Going through a very turbulent time in the relationship; or
  2. On the verge of separation or divorce.

Often, one party will make false allegations against the other to gain the upper hand in divorce or child custody proceedings

In other cases, a party may make false allegations because they caught the other having an affair and so out of anger, jealousy or bitterness, they file false charges against the cheating spouse.

The Effects

False domestic violence charges can have severe consequences for both the accused and the accuser, above and beyond their criminal implications. They can cause a great deal of familial discord and damage to relationships that both the alleged victim and perpetrator have with their children, other family members, and friends.

Furthermore, the stigma of having been accused of domestic violence can stay with the accused for a long time and can have a profound effect on both their social and professional lives, even if he or she is eventually exonerated.

Attorney for false allegations

Facing false accusations? Call (888) 250-2865 today to speak with a Law Offices of Randy Collins domestic violence attorney today for a free case evaluation. The Law Offices of Randy Collins is an A+ rated Better Business Bureau business.

  • Puccalove69

    I’m guessing men are accused more often than women. So what your really saying is that women frequently lie about domestic violence. This seems misogynistic.

    • Jac

      Misogynistic? You already made the (true) assumption that men are falsely accused more often than women. So in order for this to happen, women would therefore have to lie more often about it.

      • Puccalove69

        I said they were accused more often not falsely accused. They are accused more often because the commit domestic violence more often.

        • Linda

          This article is dead wrong as it claims that DV false allegations are “so common”. You are doing a dis-service to real victims by claiming false allegations are common. There is no data that this article is based on. As someone who has worked in the domestic violence field for over 20 years, I know that false claims of domestic violence are a small %. A report released in 2011 by the Guardian indicated that only 6 DV allegations out of 111,891 cases were false. This is 5%. When a false allegation is made, it is serious. The # of times this happens is extremely small. Other cries have much higher rates of false allegations. Randy Collins office is perpetuating a myth that has been out there for decades and works against victims getting true justice. Please delete this article and print the facts. Thank you.

          • Linda

            Correction – it is .005%

Contact us

Attorney Awards


Avvo superb attorney rating tiny (1)  Best Attorney client satisfaction award tiny (1)   better Business Bureau A+ for great lawyers tiny (1)

< /div>